White stucco home with a terracotta roof, shaded entry veranda, deep front lawn, live oak, and sea oats.

The Old Neptune Beach Kmart Has a New Plan, and This One Is Built Around a Hotel

October 22, 2026

In July 2018, Neptune Beach residents packed the Fletcher High School auditorium and spoke for more than four hours about the old Kmart site on Atlantic Boulevard. The Community Development Board then voted 6–0 to deny the proposal, WJCT reported. That plan included 175 residences. The plan the same board was scheduled to hear on Oct. 21, 2026 is described in every public account as a hotel, shops and shared parking, with no housing listed.

The new proposal is called Town Center West. Where every earlier plan had apartments, this one has a hotel twice the size of the last one, plus rows of shops. That change moves the debate. Apartments and the people who would live in them were the focus in 2018. With no housing in the plan as described, the remaining open question is the one that has run through every plan for this parcel: how cars get between Atlantic Boulevard, Lemon Street and Beaches Town Center.

Ten Years, Three Plans, One Parcel

Kmart closed at 500 Atlantic Blvd. in July 2016, and the building has been empty since, Action News Jax reported. Since then the site has drawn three development plans of very different sizes.

2017 proposal 2018 "500 Atlantic" 2026 "Town Center West"
Residences 313 apartments 175 residences None listed
Hotel None Boutique hotel, up to 74 rooms 150 rooms, about 133,580 sq ft
Commercial space 10,000 sq ft retail, possible expansion to 98,000 sq ft 107,000 sq ft commercial, retail and restaurant About 90,000 sq ft retail
Outcome Not built Denied 6–0 by the Community Development Board Before the Community Development Board, then City Council

The Jax Daily Record's 2017 report described the first plan, which covered 436, 500 and 572 Atlantic Blvd. Its first phase showed four residential buildings, two retail buildings and two smaller carriage-home structures. In its 2018 coverage, WJCT reported that the development team had first proposed five three-story apartment buildings with 199 units. The team then cut the unit count and added public parking and the hotel. That revised version went before the board. The Jax Daily Record notes that the previous redevelopment plan was not completed. The property sold in 2019, News4JAX reported.

Read across the rows, the table shows housing shrinking from plan to plan: 313 units, then 175, and none listed in 2026. The hotel goes the other way, from no hotel to 74 rooms to 150.

What the 2018 Hearing Was About

According to WJCT, the 2018 opposition raised three main concerns: traffic, parking, and Neptune Beach's small-town feel. One longtime resident said in the WJCT account that there was "already no places to park" in Beaches Town Center. Then-Police Chief Richard Pike told the board that "bringing in an apartment complex of this scope" would stretch his department and require more personnel. A Facebook group called "Neptune Beach Kmart" had grown to more than 1,500 members, and its stated goal was to stop the "big apartment complex."

The plan had supporters too. One speaker quoted by WJCT pointed to a shortage of available apartments, and another wanted something to replace the empty storefronts. On both sides, the argument was about housing.

The 2026 plan, as described so far, has no housing. The concerns about a resident population and the policing it would need came from apartments, and none are listed in this plan. The concerns that are left are the ones that would come with any busy use of the site: cars and parking.

What Town Center West Proposes

TBR Neptune is seeking a preliminary development plan approval and variances for a 133,580-square-foot hotel with 150 rooms and about 90,000 square feet of shopping center space with shared parking, according to the Jax Daily Record. The Duval County Property Appraiser lists the owner as TBR Neptune Owner, whose principal business address includes TriBridge Residential in Atlanta. Renderings released by the city show three separate structures. Action News Jax describes the hotel as three stories. First Coast News describes the retail as two rows of shops.

The name points the project toward Beaches Town Center. In a statement to First Coast News, the owner's attorney said the owner had held a public workshop with City Council where three alternative plans were discussed, and chose "the version that was most well received by the elected officials and the public that evening." The statement describes the project as "a walkable, pedestrian friendly and welcoming space with a curated mix of high end hotel, restaurants, office and retail."

City leadership is describing the project in large terms. "I think that this is the biggest development for Neptune Beach in decades," Mayor Cori Bylund told the Jax Daily Record, calling it "a tremendous opportunity for the city to have this parcel developed in a responsible way."

Lemon Street Is Where the Plan Meets the Town

Lemon Street links the Kmart parcel to Beaches Town Center and the beach. With a hotel and shops on the site, it becomes the route that carries the new traffic. First Coast News reported that the North Florida Transportation Planning Organization is studying the corridor. TPO staff walked it with city staff and reviewed what the new development might look like. Clark Letter of the TPO told the station the study will "look at alternatives and suggest design changes to better accommodate those new traffic volumes and match the aesthetics Neptune Beach is looking for in the town center area." The TPO hopes to finish "sometime around June or July."

Local businesses are already thinking about the effects. Jeremy Urbano, a server at Grumpy's, told First Coast News that a hotel within walking distance "would be amazing" for a breakfast and lunch spot, and he estimated "another 300-400 potential new customers a day" if the rooms fill. He also said the extra traffic would mean Lemon Street needs to be redone. Shawn Welk, who owns Bavarian Rennsport on Mayport Road, told Action News Jax that he supports the project. He said its developers are "replicating what they've already done on the east side of Third Street" and that "they're gonna have adequate parking."

Parking came up in 2018 and it is coming up again in 2026. The difference is that a regional transportation agency is now studying the connecting street while the project is under review. First Coast News made the same point: "That leaves two timelines to keep track of."

The Calendar From Here

The Community Development Board meeting on the variance and preliminary plan requests was set for 6 p.m. Wednesday, Oct. 21, in City Council Chambers at 116 First St. First Coast News reported that the item is then expected to go to City Council in November. The city's November calendar lists two Council dates. Neither listing says whether Town Center West is on the agenda.

  • Monday, Nov. 2, 6 p.m.: Regular City Council Meeting
  • Monday, Nov. 16, 6 p.m.: Workshop and Town Hall Council Meeting

Agendas are posted on the City of Neptune Beach calendar. In 2018, WJCT noted that City Council held the final vote on the project then under review. That remains the step to watch this time.

The next few weeks also bring events to Beaches Town Center, the district the project is named after. The free Beaches Town Center Fall Festival, with a trunk-or-treat and costume party, runs from 5 to 7 p.m. on Wednesday, Oct. 28, in the Seahorse Oceanfront Hotel parking lot at First Street and Atlantic Boulevard. The Holiday Celebration and tree lighting follows on Dec. 5, according to the Beaches Town Center calendar.

If you own a home near Atlantic Boulevard or Lemon Street and want to talk through how a pending project like Town Center West could affect your plans to sell, buy or stay put, Rory Connolly and Suzie Connolly follow these hearings closely. Contact us, and we'll keep you posted as the plan moves from the board to the Council.

Work With Us

With a strong work ethic ingrained from a young age, Rory, alongside his experienced mother, Suzie Connolly, at Ponte Vedra Club Realty, is dedicated to helping you find your perfect home. His background in finance adds a strategic edge to the process. Join Rory in building a thriving community, let's make your dream home a reality!